Old pals Ashley Olsen and Jonah Hill reunited in New York City over the weekend. Yes, the actor has been friends with Olsen, along with her sister Mary-Kate, since they were all teenagers together in Los Angeles. Hill has previously been photographed hanging out with Mary-Kate Olsen and her then-boyfriend, Olivier Sarkozy, back in 2015. On Sunday, Olsen wore a wrap coat from her own label, The Row, while Hill wore a green beanie and checked sweater.

And speaking of beanies, Hill recently honored his 24-year-old sister, Lady Bird actress Beanie Feldstein in the most permanent of ways: with a bold-lettered tattoo reading, “HELLO BEANIE,” a nod to her performance in Broadway’s Hello, Dolly! Feldstein was a fan of the ink, reposting Hill’s Instagram photo and writing, “Somebody wants to put on his Sunday clothes!!! @jonahhill - this is NEXT LEVEL. Love you!”

It’s anyone’s guess what Olsen and Hill (and their mysterious third friend dressed in all black) chatted about over the weekend. Perhaps a possible Jonah Hill x The Row beanie capsule collection? Who’s to say!